One of our clients in the do-it-yourself business recently told us they’d been offered an opportunity to be featured on a “TLC show” about home design. The client outlined the package and asked us if we thought it was worth the “sponsorship fee.”
When a “media outlet” asks for more than a product contribution or an interview, we’re always skeptical. There are a number of pay-for-play production companies out there who produce programming that feeds out to networks and stations across the country. They guarantee a specific number of airings, but can’t guarantee where or when.
We’ve vetted these types of opportunities from a number of production companies as well as print publications. They usually call saying they’ve done extensive research and their editorial team selected the company after careful consideration. Typically, they have a B- or C-list celebrity as the host. It’s not until the end of the conversation that they reveal there’s a fee – to “cover production costs.” (The print outlets generally don’t ask for a fee, but they often demand a list of the company’s partners and suppliers. Then they hound those companies for advertising, i.e. “Company X, one of your biggest customers, is being featured in our magazine. It would be a good opportunity for you to show your gratitude by supporting the publication with advertising.”)
Another red flag: These companies almost never call the client’s PR firm. Instead, they reach top executives directly to stroke their egos, hoping the person will feel honored to be selected and inclined to pay the fee for the exposure. When we call to get more information, they sometimes refuse to speak with us.
So just because a show like the one our client was considering gets picked up by TLC, it doesn’t mean your segment will air at a desirable time or at all.
When our client told us a producer from this particular show had called, the name sounded familiar. I recalled another client of ours participated in this show in the past without consulting us. I asked her to confirm my suspicion that the show was not much different than producing and distributing an infomercial.
The moral of the story: If you’re not intimately familiar with how news stories are developed, you could be misled that these types of programs hold more PR value than they actually do. If you have a significant PR budget and are looking for video that tells your story (and some exposure you can try to merchandize to your key audiences), it may be worth your consideration. A video news release will accomplish the same goals with more credibility as they’re largely aired during newscasts.
Just remember that true third-party media coverage never requires you to cut a check to a production company. For example, the same client called on by the “TLC show” contributed product to a new HGTV-produced series called “Battle on the Block” in exchange for product exposure on air and as a sponsor. That was a real editorial opportunity we endorsed without reservation.